Florida Judge: Adoption Ban Unconstitutional

Circuit Judge Cindy S. Lederman in Florida has ruled that Florida’s ban against gays adopting children is unconstitutional. The opposition is going to appeal, of course, but this is a huge victory for both the Gill family and our civil rights.

Following is the story from the Orlando Sentinel.

MIAMI – A Miami Dade Circuit judge ruled today that a gay man and his partner should be able to adopt the two foster children they have raised for four years.

Circuit Judge Cindy S. Lederman “these children are thriving. These words we don’t often hear within these walls. That’s uncontroverted,” said Circuit Judge Cindy S. Lederman.

“They’re a good family. They’re a family in every way except in the eyes of the law. These children have a right to permanency,” the judge said. “The only real permanency is adoption in the home where they are thriving.

“There is no rational basis to preclude homosexuals from adopting,” Lederman continued.

When he heard those words, Frank Martin Gill patted his eyes with a folded white tissue.

In 2004, the state encouraged Gill and his unidentified male partner to provide a foster home for two boys. Gill wants to become their adopted father.

“Today I’ve cried my first tears of joy in my life,” said Gill, 47, a flight attendant who lives in North Miami. “We are elated.” Gill added: “I wasn’t here to make history. I was here to do the best thing for a 4- and an 8-year-old.”

A lawyer from the Attorney General’s Office, who is representing the state Department of Children and Families, said the case would be appealed.

Some states, such as Mississippi and Utah, prevent gays from adopting by using laws that prohibit unmarried couples from adopting. But Florida expressly targeted gays with its 1977 law, enacted during former Miss America Anita Bryant’s anti-homosexual crusade.

Florida Statute 63.042 states: “No person eligible to adopt under this statute may adopt if that person is a homosexual.” They can be state-appointed foster parents. They can be named permanent guardians. But adoption is not allowed.

Gill’s attorney, Robert Rosenwald of the American Civil Liberties Union of Florida, said an appeals court and the possibly the Florida Supreme Court would be asked to address the ban on gay adoption.

My congratulations to the Gill family. What a special Thanksgiving for them.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
  • Share/Bookmark

(Please read the comment tips before joining the conversation.)

  • Huge victory, and the opposition has already started shouting that Judge Lederman is an activist judge and she should be voted out and blah blah blah. You know the drill. The appeal, though, comes from the state attorney general on behalf of the state's Department of Children & Families.

    Hopefully the Gills have been able to shield their children from most of this. I saw one news report from the Baltimore Examiner reporting that the boys are practicing writing their new last names.

    That sound you just heard was my heart melting.
  • Yeah, I heard about that on NPR this evening. I told Shannon about it when I got home. It's a great victory, especially in Florida where the laws are more strict than any other state concerning Gay Adoption.

    Shannon and I both are absolutely disgusted that people are already trying to appeal the decision. As if the children haven't been through enough already.

    Regardless, it's an incredible victory; and I'm glad this will hopefully give the topic much needed discussion and debate.

    Thanks for the post.
blog comments powered by Disqus