Gay Man Decapitated, Dismembered; Investigator Sides with Killer

November 16, 2009

Brace yourself. This one gets ugly fast.

The following was published late last night through CNN’s iReport network by Christopher Pagan about Thursday’s grisly murder of Jorge Steven López Mercado in Puerto Rico. (h/t TowleRoad)

I am writing to you about a tragic murder that has happened here in Puerto Rico. It has really only made local news simply because we are on this island, but you are the voice of those that are unheard throughout the world. On November 14 the body of a gay 19 year old was found a few miles away from the town in which he was residing in called Caguas. He was a very well known person in the gay community of Puerto Rico, and very loved. He was found on the site of an isolated road in the city of Cayey, he was partially burned, decapitated, and dismembered, both arms, both legs, and the torso.

This has caused a huge reaction from the gay community here, but its a difficult situation. Never in the history of Puerto Rico has a murder been classified as a hate crime. Even though we have to follow federal mandates and laws, many of the laws in which are passed in the USA such as Obama’s new bill, do not always directly get practiced in Puerto Rico. The police agent that is handling this case said on a public televised statement that “people who lead this type of lifestyle need to be aware that this will happen”. As If the boy murdered Jorge Steven López was asking to get killed.

We have a gay rights activist in Puerto Rico Pedro Julio Serrano. Who does his best to defend [against] these hateful acts, but the international attention is needed for this local government to wake up and give us the needed rights and proper justice to such hateful crimes. You are the biggest beacon of hope in such horrific events to be made known.

Jorge Steven López Mercado

Jorge Steven López Mercado
1990 - 2009

According to Primera Hora, friends became worried (auto-translate from Google) last Thursday when Steven didn’t show up at Road to Diva, an event at local gay club Krash that he’d told friends earlier in the day that he would attend.

Puerto Rico Para Tod@s‘s Pedro Julio Serrano released a statement (in Spanish (pdf)) yesterday that reads in part:

It is inconceivable that the investigating officer suggests that the victim deserved his fate, like a woman deserves rape for wearing a short skirt. We demand condemnation of this investigator and demand that Superintendente Figueroa Sancha replace him with someone capable of investigating this case without prejudice.

This is why we fight, folks. Other attacks and indignities LGBT people suffer look slight in comparison to this murder, but it all comes from the same fear and hatred, and far too many people in straight America quietly agree with the investigator.

My prayers, insufficient as they are, go out to Steven’s family and friends.



  • Pingback: uberVU - social comments

  • Brooke

    …I think I'm going to be sick,

  • Nick

    He Deserved Nothing like that,,,Being gay is NOT wrong…it is NOT a choice…NO ONE Should Die for being Gay…i hope the people who did should die the same wat this kid did…Make them pay!!!….from the sound of it it seems the investigator may have had an involvement in this murder!!!

  • Nickalick

    He Deserved Nothing like that,,,Being gay is NOT wrong…it is NOT a choice…NO ONE Should Die for being Gay…i hope the people who did should die the same wat this kid did…Make them pay!!!….from the sound of it it seems the investigator may have had an involvement in this murder!!!

  • Robinson

    Let unit force and writte letter to the police department and the governor for proper action and a proper investigation in this case, This is worst than the matthew shepard case

  • Pingback: Arrest Made in Brutal Puerto Rico Murder | Asterisk

  • Pingback: Puerto Rican Murderer Confesses, Uses Gay Panic Defense | Asterisk

  • Just Wondering

    Am I alone in how I took the investigator's comment…As a police officer, I am sure he is more than aware of the intolerance that may be in the area for alternative lifestyles…and what he said was just warning others, that they need to watch out for themselves and be aware of their surroundings b/c they are more likely to be victims? Nothing in his comment (in this article at least) makes him out to be siding with the killer or that the victim deserved this…I am not saying this was not a hate crime and it is absolutely horrible and very sad, I am just a little uncertain as to where the anger is coming from towards the investigator…

  • http://blog.mattalgren.com Matt Algren

    I suspect that some of the meaning is lost in translation. I'm trusting the unusually visceral reaction from the Puerto Rico LGBT community as an indicator for his meaning.

    Regardless, the appropriate reaction from an investigator is not to warn the victim's community to watch their backs. (Trust me, they already know that.) The appropriate reaction is to make clear to the murderer's community that it won't be tolerated. The investigator chose the former.

  • http://blog.mattalgren.com Matt Algren

    Fortunately, the monster who did this has confessed and is in custody, so at least the local community can come down from red alert.

  • BillyD

    Could it be that the lifestyle that the investigator was referring to was not Jorge's being gay, but to his alleged status as a cross-dressing sex worker? Not that gay hookers deserve to be killed, but that it's a risky business?

  • http://blog.mattalgren.com Matt Algren

    As I said above, I trust the Puerto Rico community's response, not to mention that of Pedro Julio Serrano, as a good indicator that he was basically saying, “Yeah, well, that's what happens” and shrugging his shoulders.

    And again, even accepting your alternate interpretation it's a wholly inappropriate official response to a man being murdered, beheaded, sawed into pieces, and burned.

    I understand the urge to explain away a statement so shocking. I honestly do. Sometimes, though, people say and do harmful things. When that happens, no good is served by covering them up rather than facing them.

  • soniarodriguezlopez

    I am a 45 yr old Puerto Rican mother, sister, friend. Forget gay bi or straight Please everyone who sees this know that we are an American territory. My great grand parents, grandparents and uncles all fought in the Army. I am as American as Apple pie and this makes me sick. This young man needs justice and in a small island like in rural small town USA sometimes the Law enforcement agencies are lacking. Yet its you and I and the rest of this world to choose to get involved soooo these victims and their parents will see justice. I am Puerto Rican American and I am Love… Please do not judge us for some maniac. LIVE LOVE AND LAUGH GOD BLESS US ALL

  • stevensandrew

    i agree with u. It's like telling a blk person back in the 50's “you're bound to get hang on a tree, you know it's coming for you. Cause your blk. so stop being black.”

  • Pingback: Houston Gay Kid Beaten with Metal Pipe; School Officials Refused to Help | Asterisk

  • http://blog.mattalgren.com Matt Algren

    I agree with you 100%, Sonia. I'm so glad you took the time to comment.

  • karls0913

    People need to stay away from Puerto Rico; the crime, drug, and gay bashing capital of the world.

  • http://blog.mattalgren.com Matt Algren

    A bit much.

  • http://blog.mattalgren.com Matt Algren

    A bit much.

  • Pingback: Puerto Rico Murder and Texas Assault to be Prosecuted as Hate Crimes | Asterisk

  • gaysleavemialone

    all gays should die

  • Pingback: Justice for Steven Lopez | Asterisk