Archive for DADT category
Lt. Col. Fehrenbach: How is DADT working?
As I heard Senator John McCain and others repeat the claim yesterday that “Don’t Ask Don’t Tell is working”, I couldn’t help but wonder how in the world they could come to that conclusion.
Fortunately for me, Lt. Col. Victor Fehrenbach had the same question, which he asked on The Rachel Maddow Show last night.
Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
Also from The Rachel Maddow Show, Senator McCain is a big ole hypocrite when it comes to DADT. (He’s a hypocrite in a lot of other ways, but let’s stay on task.)
Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
Finally, here’s a tweet from the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Admiral Mike Mullen. I cannot overstate the importance of his support yesterday. Neither can I overstate my appreciation for it.
FRC’s Peter Sprigg: We should outlaw “gay behavior”
Posted by Matt in California, DADT, Hate Crimes, Marriage, News, Politics on February 2nd, 2010
Today saw the first hearings on Don’t Ask Don’t Tell (DADT) in over a decade. It was a fun-filled day that I’ll probably talk about in some depth later in the week, but this video needed to be posted immediately.
Peter Sprigg of the Family Research Council (a sister company to Focus on the Family) was on Hardball with Chris Matthews tonight alongside SLDN’s Aubrey Sarvis to talk about DADT. This video should be set to the last thirty seconds of the segment when Sprigg let the cat out of the bag. See transcript below.
Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy
Matthews: Do you think we should outlaw gay behavior?
Sprigg: Well, I think certainly it’s defensible.
Matthews: No, I’m just asking you, should we outlaw gay behavior?
Sprigg: I think that the Supreme Court decision in Lawrence v Texas, which overturned the sodomy laws in this country, was wrongly decided. I think there would be a place for criminal sanctions against homosexual behavior.
Matthews: So we should outlaw gay behavior.
Sprigg: Yes. [laughs]
Keep in mind that a year ago, Peter Sprigg said that gays should face more taxes than straight people, and a year before that he went on television to suggest that gays be rounded up and “exported”.
Make no mistake: Peter Sprigg is one of the few anti-gay leaders who actually speaks his mind, and the rest of them are thinking exactly what he says. I shudder to think what he keeps to himself.
Incidentally, I hope someone thinks to enter this video into evidence in Perry v Schwarzenegger, the Prop 8 trial. If ever we had evidence of anti-gay animus being whipped up, this is it.
(Hat tip to Alvin McEwen.)
Too Late to Save Careers of Choi and Fehrenbach?
The US Senate held confirmation hearings today for Dr. Clifford Stanley, nominatee for the position of Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness. This is important to Don’t Ask Don’t Tell (DADT) watchers because that officer usually deals with DADT cases. We’d hoped to get a glimpse at the Obama Administration’s handling of the theoretical repeal of the discriminatory law.
From my count, we got two indications from today’s hearing.
Sen. John McCain’s opening remarks include the statement that “this policy has worked successfully in my view.” (via Kerry Eleveld’s twitter stream) I would hardly call Sen. McCain moderate, especially considering his unabashedly anti-gay statements during last year’s failed campaign for the presidency, but it’s still disheartening to hear such nonsense go unchallenged.
More troublesome, though, is Dr. Stanley’s response to a question from Sen. Roland Burris of Illinois about what happens to current DADT investigations if DADT is repealed. Stanley’s answer was, “if there are pending cases, they would fall under the existing statute. That’s about all I can say about that at this time.” (again from Kerry Eleveld’s coverage)
We had hoped, or at least I had hoped, that DADT’s repeal would end the destruction of honorable servicemembers’ lives. That doesn’t seem to be the case, at least not according to the testimony of this candidate.

Lt. Choi and Lt. Col. Fehrenbach
Based on this testimony I have to wonder: Is it too late? Should current DADT victims give up their personal fights for justice to save their veterans benefits? It might be too late to save their careers, but can they save their futures?
Lt. Dan Choi came home from an extended tour of duty in Iraq with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). If he gets a less-than-honorable discharge (which is guaranteed if he fights his firing), he will lose his veteran health benefits and, at least to my understanding, his PTSD would be used as a preexisting condition to deny coverage from health insurance companies.
Lt. Col. Victor Fehrenbach is now about a year away from his 20-year retirement date. Remember, if he continues to fight for justice, he will lose retirement funds of $46,000 per year for the rest of his life, all of the lifetime veteran health benefits he has earned, and $80,000 in separation pay.
All this because the cases came a year before congress had the courage to act.
Is this how America treats its veterans? Is it really?
Veterans Day: Thank You Captain Mike Rankin, MD (Ret.)
Captain Mike Rankin, M.D., MC, USN (Ret.) served from 1964 to 1988. A doctor, he selflessly protected lesbian and gay servicemembers from harm under the anti-gay policy that predates Don’t Ask Don’t Tell.
I’ve been saving his story for about a month now, since Capt. Rankin marched beside Lt. Dan Choi at the Leonard Matlovich Memorial. Forgive me from breaking my self imposed word limit and Veterans Day format, but this hero is more important.
A gay man himself, semi-closeted by necessity, Capt. Rankin refused to “diagnose” anyone as homosexual, or to refer a gay person to a clergymember who he didn’t know would be affirming. Countless lives–countless–were saved from ruin or worse by Capt. Rankin* . The following is only part of his story, told in a speech in 2006. Please, please, please, follow the link and read the whole thing.
“Permission to join the mess, Captain,” he panted. “Sorry to be late sir—a couple faggots wanted a tour of the ship and I had to chase them away.”
All morning we’d been offering tours to families and to young women eager to meet a sailor. This was routine when we were not underway. The Navy considered these ship visits great public relations, as long as the visitors were heterosexual families and single women. Men who might be gay need not apply.
“Permission granted, Lieutenant,” the captain replied. “Take your seat.” Conversation around the table continued.
I sat there seething, staring at my plate. Faggot. Faggot. It rang in my ears. And I began to remember all the times during the 24 years when I’d listened without comment to shipboard homophobic slurs and “jokes.”
I thought of all the conversations started, in sickbay or on the bridge at sea, and then broken off, because a shipmate wasn’t sure I wouldn’t turn him in if he told me his secret. I thought of the gutsy sailors who did take the risk, because of their own courage, and because scuttlebutt had it—correctly for once– that what was said in my sickbay stayed there. I was safe to talk to.
But so often I had remained silent in my medical office, letting those who needed to talk “teach me” about gay life. For whatever reason, I couldn’t simply say “I understand. I’m gay too. I know what it’s like to come out to a close friend or family member who’s promised ‘unconditional love,’ only to find that love wasn’t so unconditional after all. I know about being in the closet at work, making up fictitious dates with the opposite sex. And buddy I know exactly what it’s like to lose a lover—it hurts like hell.” Those empathetic words remained largely unsaid. The Navy was my last closet—until that June lunch in the wardroom.
Sitting at the table with those men, I felt my cool rationality slipping away. I ceased to be a medical officer and a role model for the corpsmen under my command. I was no longer a psychiatrist trained to understand motivation and behavior. I had no more excuses for all the young officers who responded to peer pressure with pathetic attempts to be “more macho than thou.” And I had no more excuses for my own silence; that silence was compliance.
Right there in the wardroom, before God and the whole U.S Navy, I became simply one pissed off queer.
Facing the immediate source of my discontent, who was happily eating away, I commented in what I thought was a quiet conversational tone of voice, “Lt. Jones, I was offended by your use of the word ‘faggot.’ Using that word is like calling someone a nigger, a spick, wop, kike or cunt. It automatically defines one as a bigot. Bigotry, Lieutenant, is not a quality the Navy usually looks for when it selects its officers for promotion. Now that you know that, I’m sure you’ll not use the term again.”
He sat there with the chipped beef on his fork, halfway between his plate and his open mouth. The other officers looked from him to me and back, speechless.
For about fifteen long seconds I felt like I’d just told the dentist, “oh forget the novocaine, just go ahead and drill,” one of those remarks you instantly want to retract.
But I couldn’t retract it. It hung there in the air. I thought if I didn’t say something to get us past the moment, the room would explode. “Captain, would you please pass the catsup,” I asked calmly, “My beef’s a little tough.” The captain passed the catsup, there were sighs of relief, and the talk turned again to the Niners vs the Raiders.
Again, click through to keep reading. This is not the end of the story.
Captain Rankin, you have no idea the good you’ve done. Thank you so very much for serving your country.

* Incidentally, that strategy is not possible under DADT. Just yesterday, the American Medical Association called for the repeal of Don’t Ask Don’t Tell, because doctors may be and have been required to break confidentiality in order to out a lesbian or gay person who thought they were safe talking to their doctor.
Veterans Day: Thank You Sgt. Bleu Copas
Linguist and Army Sergeant Bleu Copas served from 2002 to 2006, when he was outed by an anonymous tip telling Army officials to break Don’t Ask Don’t Tell policy by asking Sgt. Copas if he was gay. They did. They also asked Sgt. Copas if he knew any gay people and if he was ever involved in community theater.
While he complied with the Don’t Ask Don’t Tell law by refusing to answer “the question” without legal representation, the investigation continued until he was finally fired for being gay.

Sgt. Copas, thank you for serving your country.

